In reality want to see if one member, "3667" from the CBA table has paid his dues in one table or the other.
SELECT c.CBA_ID, c.LNAME, c.FN_MI, p.itemnumber, d.DUES_YEAR
FROM ((CBA c
LEFT JOIN DUES_PAID d ON d.CBA_ID=c.CBA_ID)
LEFT JOIN paypal_payment_info p ON p.custom=c.CBA_ID)
WHERE c.CBA_ID = 3667 AND d.DUES_YEAR =2008 OR p.itemnumber = 2009
ORDER BY c.LNAME ASC