It first showed me only one reply (it was the text from Jenny's second post under chriscozi's name.) But I knew I had replied to this thread yesterday and that the reply count was 3, so I refreshed it. Then it showed chriscozi's real reply and my first reply, but not Jenny's. After refreshing it a couple more times, it finally showed all the replies.
Don't know if this type of anomaly is happening to anyone else.